What Shopify does well day to day, where fees, apps and fixed structures slow growing online shops down, and who the platform suits in the UK.
Day to day, Shopify is a calm, fast platform for merchants with a manageable product range. Hosting, security and updates run without your involvement, a team learns the admin in a few days, and the checkout is one of the strongest on the market. A standard shop can be live within a few weeks.
The downsides usually appear in the second year. Fees per sale, many paid apps, fixed URL structures and limits in checkout, data model and integrations cost growing shops money and room to move. If you need your own processes, B2B logic or a tight connection to your ERP, you hit limits sooner than the product pages suggest.
The real question is not whether Shopify is good, but whether it fits your business model. If you do not want to handle setup and operation yourself, there are ready-made packages as well, for example our shop subscription from £299 per month, which we deliver on Shopify, Shopware or WooCommerce.
This article is for managing directors, e-commerce managers and marketing leads who plan to adopt Shopify or already use it and want to know what holds up in daily work and where it struggles. It is based on our work as an agency that builds with both Shopify and Shopware, and on Shopify’s official documentation. Experience-based figures and sample calculations are labelled as such.
solution25 is an e-commerce agency based in Bremen, Germany. Since our founding in 2017 we have built shops with Shopware, now as a Platinum Partner, and we also deliver Shopify projects. We earn money with both platforms. That matters for how you read this: we have no interest in talking Shopify down, but no reason to hide its weaknesses either.
This is not a review with points and stars. It collects what we encounter again and again in consulting, implementation and operation: questions merchants ask before launch, problems that show up after go-live, and decisions that later turn out to be expensive.
We look at five points, because they decide between success and frustration in daily work:
You will find the exact Shopify plan prices in our article on Shopify costs and the direct platform comparison under Shopify or Shopware. This article covers the practice in between.
Shopify’s strengths lie where many merchants spend most of their effort: technical operation and selling to consumers. These points hold up in almost every project.
Shopify is a hosted, rented platform. Servers, security updates, certificates and traffic peaks are handled by Shopify. You do not plan updates, you do not install patches, and on Black Friday nobody on your team worries about server capacity. For a merchant without an IT department, that is the single biggest advantage. With a self-operated system such as Shopware, updates and hosting are your responsibility or that of your service provider.
Creating products, processing orders, setting up discounts: the interface is tidy and available in many languages. In our experience, a team from sales and marketing works independently after a few days. That saves training time and makes you less dependent on an agency for small changes.
The standard checkout is fast, works well on mobile and comes with express payments such as Shop Pay. On its pricing page, Shopify claims an average conversion rate 15 % higher than on other platforms. That figure is a vendor claim we cannot verify independently. Our own observation is more cautious: the checkout works reliably without customisation, and that is not a given with many platforms.
Reviews, subscriptions, product filters, legal texts, shipping labels: for nearly every requirement there are several providers in the App Store. You can extend a shop quickly without writing code. We cover the downside in the next section.
With Shopify Markets you sell from one shop into several countries. Prices can be shown in local currency, each market can get its own subfolder or domain, and Shopify sets the hreflang tags automatically. According to Shopify, the free Translate & Adapt app translates automatically into up to two languages, and you maintain further translations by hand. As a first step abroad, that is solid.
If you also sell in a shop or at markets, you can use Shopify’s own point of sale system and keep inventory and customers in one place. Sales channels such as social networks or marketplaces can be connected through apps.
Shopify’s weaknesses are not bugs but consequences of its model: a rented platform for millions of merchants has to stay uniform. What makes life easier for a small shop becomes a limit for a growing one.
If you process payments through a provider other than Shopify Payments, you pay additional transaction fees according to the Shopify Help Center, and their amount depends on your plan. The payment provider charges its own fees on top. With small revenue, this barely shows. With six-figure monthly revenue it becomes a noticeable cost that many did not plan for at launch.
Every app is a separate contract with its own billing cycle. The Help Center explicitly points out that app subscriptions are not billed in step with your Shopify invoice. In practice we see three problems: the total of app fees grows unnoticed, data is spread across different providers, and every app brings its own script that can slow the shop down. If you cancel an app, its data and functions are often gone immediately.
Shopify defines many things that you cannot change. Products always live under /products/, categories under /collections/, content pages under /pages/. The checkout can only be adapted within set boundaries. For most shops this is no problem. For merchants with an established URL structure or special ordering processes, it is a real limitation.
Shopify knows products, variants, collections and freely definable extra fields (metafields). Many product ranges can be modelled well with these. Configurators, bills of materials, customer-specific prices with many tiers, or products with dependencies between options, however, need apps or custom development.
To connect your ERP, PIM or warehouse, you use Shopify’s APIs. They have fixed limits: requests are throttled by cost or count, according to the developer documentation a single request accepts at most 250 items in an input list, and paging through data stops after 25,000 objects. That is enough for most shops. For large catalogues with frequent price and inventory changes, the integration needs careful planning.
Shopify decides where your shop data is stored. For many merchants that is fine. For industries with strict requirements or companies with a clear data protection policy, it can rule the platform out. Clarify this with your data protection officer before the decision, not after.
The monthly fee for the Shopify plan is easy to compare and in growing shops rarely the largest item. The costs we see underestimated most often arise per sale and per app. We have broken down current plan prices and card fees in our article on Shopify costs.
| Cost item | What it depends on | Common mistake |
|---|---|---|
| Plan | Chosen plan, monthly or annual billing | Putting only this amount in the budget |
| Payment fees | Revenue, payment method, Shopify Payments or third-party provider | Overlooking the extra fee for third-party providers |
| Apps | Number and plans of apps, often tiered by orders | Trials rolling into paid plans unnoticed |
| Theme and customisation | Purchased theme or custom development | Undocumented changes that get lost in a theme update |
| Support | In-house team or agency | No budget planned for ongoing maintenance |
The following example is hypothetical and only meant to show the order of magnitude. A merchant makes 50,000 € in revenue per month. Half of it runs through a payment provider outside Shopify Payments. If we assume an additional transaction fee of 1 % on that share, that is 250 € per month or 3,000 € per year, on top of the payment provider’s own fees. Add eight apps at an average of 20 € per month, which is 160 € per month or 1,920 € per year. Together that is almost 5,000 € per year before a single hour of support has been paid. Run this example with your real numbers and the plan you would choose.
Many merchants want neither to build the shop themselves nor to pay a one-off project invoice. For this case we offer the shop subscription. According to the current page there are three packages, each with a minimum term of 24 months, a new shop without setup fee and a 10 % saving with annual payment:
Scale and Pro apply to shops with up to 1 million € in annual revenue, and after 24 months the shop belongs to you. Important for Shopify: you pay the Shopify fees separately and directly to Shopify, and Shopify takes care of hosting. Hosting in German data centres applies to Shopware and WooCommerce.
Shopify is an international platform. The interface is translated, but the platform does not take over the legal obligations of your market. These points should be settled before go-live.
Legal notice, terms and conditions, cancellation policy and privacy policy are your responsibility. Many merchants use apps from legal text providers that update texts automatically. New obligations such as a withdrawal function in the shop also require technical implementation, more on this in our article on the withdrawal button.
Customers expect more than credit cards. Depending on the market, digital wallets, buy now pay later or invoice payment are standard for many target groups. Check early which payment methods you can offer through Shopify Payments and which require a third-party provider, because that affects fees.
In the UK, standard VAT is 20 %, with reduced rates of 5 % and 0 %. Set up all three rates in the tax settings and check that your theme shows prices including VAT. Personal data falls under UK GDPR, so review apps and cookie consent with that in mind. Since Brexit, parcels to EU customers need customs declarations. For consignments up to 150 € in value, the EU import scheme IOSS lets you collect VAT at checkout, which avoids surprise charges for your customers on delivery.
Themes and apps are often built for one market first. Check every visible string: basket, shipping notes, customer emails. Half-finished translations look unprofessional and cost trust.
Shopify provides solid foundations for search engine optimisation. That is enough for most shops. For SEO-driven business models there are limits.
Fixed paths such as /products/ and /collections/ cannot be changed. If you switch from another platform, every old URL needs a redirect. Some themes also link products through collection paths. The canonical then points to the product URL, but you should still check your theme’s internal linking. The blog is functional but basic: for a large guide archive with author profiles and a complex structure, many merchants turn to apps or external solutions.
More and more purchase decisions start in AI assistants. Clear product data, clean categories and well-structured guides help more here than any single measure. How to show AI systems the way to your most important content is described in our article on llms.txt.
How well Shopify fits depends heavily on your product range and your system landscape. These are the points we ask about in every requirements workshop.
Until autumn 2025 the limit was 100 variants per product. According to the Shopify developer changelog of 15 October 2025, all merchants can now use up to 2,048 variants per product. That is a real improvement for fashion, spare parts and configurable products. Shopify does point out, however, that apps still using older APIs may work in a limited or broken way with products that have more than 100 variants. Check your apps before you create large variant products.
Technical attributes, care instructions or downloads are stored in metafields and metaobjects. That works well but needs planning: which fields do you need, who maintains them, and how do they get from your PIM or ERP into the shop?
According to the Shopify Help Center, B2B features are now available on the Basic, Grow, Advanced and Plus plans, with company profiles, custom catalogues and customer-specific settings. How far that goes for your business depends on pricing logic, approval processes and ERP. We cover this topic in a separate article.
The connection runs through ready-made connectors, middleware or a custom integration. In our experience, this is where it is decided whether a Shopify project stays on budget. Clarify early: which system holds prices, inventory and customers? How often does data need to flow? What happens if one side fails? Very large catalogues face additional limits: according to the developer documentation, once a shop has 500,000 variants, it can create no more than 10,000 new variants per day, and Shopify Plus is exempt.
The checkout is the reason many merchants choose Shopify, and at the same time the area where you decide the least yourself.
You adjust colours, logo, fonts and some fields in the checkout editor. Additional content and logic come through apps and extensions. Until August 2024, Shopify Plus merchants could also freely design the checkout with their own template file. According to the Shopify changelog, such customisations on the information, shipping and payment pages have stopped working since 13 August 2024. They were replaced by the new extension model, which is more secure and upgrade-safe but leaves less freedom.
Our experience: merchants who accept the standard checkout are very happy with Shopify. Merchants who want to rebuild their old checkout one to one rarely are.
Our projects give a fairly clear picture. The table summarises typical requirements. It does not replace a requirements analysis, but it helps with a first assessment.
| Requirement | Shopify fits well | Rather Shopware or a custom solution |
|---|---|---|
| Product range | Up to a few thousand products, clear variants | Configurators, bills of materials, many dependencies |
| Customer groups | Consumers, simple business customers | Complex B2B pricing, approvals, budgets |
| In-house IT | No tech team of your own | Own team or a dedicated agency for operation |
| Checkout | Standard flow is enough | Custom ordering processes are part of the business model |
| Data location | No special requirements | Servers in a specific country or own infrastructure required |
| Cost model | Predictable monthly costs, small launch budget | High revenue where fees per sale weigh heavily |
You will find the detailed comparison of both platforms under Shopify or Shopware. If you are considering the opposite route, the article Switching from Shopware to Shopify covers process and effort. Shopify Plus, the most important apps and alternatives to Shopify are covered in separate articles.
We see the following mistakes again and again. None of them is dramatic, but together they cost time, money and patience.
Yes, often very much so. If you want to launch quickly without a tech team and have a manageable product range, you benefit most from the hosted model. Still, calculate fees and apps honestly.
Many merchants in the EU use Shopify. Whether your shop complies with data protection rules depends on your setup: data processing agreements, cookie consent and above all the apps you use. There is no blanket answer, so clarify this with your data protection advisor.
In our experience, a shop with a purchased theme and a manageable product range is ready within a few weeks. Individual design, data migration and ERP integration extend the project to several months. The biggest time factor is usually product data and decisions, not the technology.
Yes. Products and customers can be exported, and orders and further data via the API. The effort lies in redirects, app data and custom changes. If you already know a switch is possible, keep your data clean and as independent from individual apps as you can.
Not necessarily for a simple shop. An agency pays off when design, data migration, integrations or an SEO migration are on the agenda, or when you want to hand over operation entirely.
We build with Shopify and Shopware and therefore advise without being tied to one platform. If you are unsure whether Shopify fits your business, we look at your requirements and tell you openly which platform we would choose in your place, even if it is not the one you expected.
For an existing shop, the shop analysis is a good starting point. If you want to hand over setup and operation entirely, you will find packages and prices in the shop subscription. Read more about our work with Shopify on our Shopify agency page. And if you would rather talk directly, you can reach us through the contact form.

Henrik Schäfer is a TÜV-certified data protection officer and handles privacy and compliance topics in ecommerce projects at solution25. He helps merchants put privacy requirements into practice without losing sight of conversion. Get in touch
Responsible for content and updates: Henrik Schäfer. Last updated: November 2026. Next content review: February 2027.