The return rate falls when customers know what they will get before they buy: ten measures with notes for UK retailers.
The return rate falls when customers know what they will get before they buy. Most returns happen because size, colour, material or function do not match the expectation. Better product information therefore works harder than stricter return rules.
Ten measures apply at three points: on the product page, in the ordering process and after shipping. Which of them works for you only becomes clear when you evaluate the return reasons. Without recorded reasons you are flying blind.
You cannot optimise away the right of withdrawal, but you can address the causes. Under German and EU rules, consumers have 14 days to withdraw from a distance contract. How cleanly you handle returns in the store also depends on your system. If you want to hand over setup and operations, you will find the packages in the shop subscription.
This article is for managing directors, e-commerce leads and customer service managers whose margin suffers from returns. You will learn how to calculate the rate correctly, what a return costs, which ten measures address the causes and what applies legally.
The return rate states what share of the shipped goods comes back. That sounds clear, but it is not. There are three common ways to calculate it, and they produce different numbers.
| Metric | Formula | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|
| By parcel | Returned parcels divided by shipped parcels | Shows the load on logistics and service |
| By item | Returned items divided by shipped items | Shows how well products match the expectation |
| By value | Value of returned goods divided by value of shipped goods | Shows the effect on revenue |
The numbers are a made-up example. A store ships 1,000 parcels with 2,400 items worth 96,000 euros in one month. 220 parcels with 380 items worth 19,000 euros come back. By parcel that is 22 percent, by item just under 16 percent, by value just under 20 percent. Three numbers for the same month.
Decide which number you report and stick with it. For working on the causes, the item-based rate per product and per category is the most useful. It shows which items cause the problem.
According to a retailer survey by the Returns Management Research Group at the University of Bamberg, almost every fourth parcel in German online retail was sent back in 2021. That was around 530 million return shipments with about 1.3 billion items. For 2018 the same research group put shoes and clothing at almost every second parcel, and electronics and books at low single-digit values. So your industry determines what a good rate is.
A return costs more than the return postage. Add up all the items before you decide on measures.
In 2022 the research group in Bamberg put transport and handling costs at about 2.85 euros per returned item. In the survey for 2018 the figure was around 11 euros per item including postage. The range shows how strongly the result depends on product range, volume and processing. Do not rely on averages. Calculate your own figure.
An example with assumed numbers: 4.50 euros return postage, 3 euros for ten minutes of handling, 2 euros average loss of value and 0.50 euros payment fee add up to 10 euros per return. With 220 returns per month that is 2,200 euros. If the number falls by a fifth, you save 440 euros per month and get back goods that stay sellable right away. With this calculation you can assess every measure: what does it cost, and how many returns does it have to prevent to pay for itself?
Each measure only works against a specific reason. So record the reason for every return, per item and not per parcel.
Offer five to eight fixed reasons to choose from and a free text field. Too many options lead customers to click the first one. For fit, ask about the direction: too big or too small. This one extra question turns a return reason into a hint for the size chart. Evaluate the reasons monthly per product. Ten items often cause a large share of the returns.
The product page is where expectations are formed. The most effective measures apply here.
A general size chart helps little if your brands fit differently. State the measured dimensions per product and say clearly whether an item runs small, true to size or large. Use the feedback from the returns for this. If 30 out of 40 returns for an item give too small as the reason, the hint to order one size up belongs on the page.
Show the product from several angles, in use and with a size comparison. Colours should be right in daylight. A short video shows material and drape better than five photos. Beautiful images sell. Honest images sell in a way that the goods stay.
Write down what customers need to know and what the manufacturer leaves out: weight, dimensions, material, scope of delivery, what the product is not suitable for. The last point costs individual sales and saves more returns. The questions from customer service are the best source for these texts.
Ask buyers in the review for their height, the size ordered and a verdict on the fit. Other customers trust this information more than any chart. Leave critical reviews in place too. They prevent purchases by customers who would have sent the goods back anyway.
If the same item is in the basket in two sizes, a return is very likely. A friendly note in the basket with a link to the size advice helps some customers decide. You should not forbid the selection order. Customers who feel patronised buy elsewhere.
The Bamberg researchers name purchase on invoice as one reason for high return numbers in Germany. In their 2022 survey its share was 28.8 percent among German retailers and 9.9 percent in the rest of Europe. But purchase on invoice also brings revenue. Instead of removing it, you can control it through rules, for example only from the second order or up to a certain order value. Which providers exist is shown in the comparison of payment providers for Shopware.
Goods that arrive too late go back. Show the delivery time per product and keep to it. Shortly after the order, give customers the option to correct the size or address or to cancel. A cancelled order costs almost nothing. A return costs postage, time and often margin. This matters especially before Christmas. More on this in the article on the Christmas season in the online shop.
Transport damage and wrongly packed parcels are avoidable returns. Check items with a noticeably high number of damages: is it the packaging, the carrier or the product? A second check at the packing station, for example by scan, reduces wrong deliveries. If stock and product data do not match, a clean connection of the ERP system to Shopware helps.
Many returns of products that need explanation are in fact operating problems. An email two days after delivery with instructions, a video and a contact for service catches some of them. In the returns portal, ask for the reason before the label appears, and offer help right away for operating problems.
Someone with the wrong size usually wants the right one. Offer the exchange as the first route in the returns portal, with reserved goods. That keeps the revenue. Whether you cover return costs is a separate decision. According to the Bamberg survey, 88.7 percent of German retailers offered free returns, compared with 52.4 percent in the rest of Europe. Paid returns lower the rate but can also cost orders. Test it on one category before you introduce it for the whole store.
This section gives an overview of German law, which implements EU consumer rules, and does not replace legal advice. Have your withdrawal policy and your return rules checked for the countries you sell to.
Two things follow from this. First, you cannot restrict the right of withdrawal through conditions. Second, you have room to decide on return costs if your policy is correct. What the withdrawal button means for your store is explained in the article on the withdrawal button.
United Kingdom: The rules above are German law. In the UK, the Consumer Contracts Regulations give consumers 14 days to cancel most online purchases, so have your policy checked for the UK separately. Refunds adjust VAT at the rate of the item, that is 20%, 5% or 0%. If you store return reasons together with customer data, UK GDPR applies. For customers in the EU, returns cross a customs border, so explain the process clearly. The euro amounts in this article are not converted.
Many stores advertise 30 or 100 days of returns. That is a voluntary service on top of the right of withdrawal, and you may set conditions for it. According to the Bamberg survey, German retailers granted 51.7 days on average, retailers in the rest of Europe 28.1 days. A long period is a selling point. But it also increases the time during which goods are in transit.
Measures need a system that supplies data. In Shopware several building blocks work together for this.
Shopware lists returns management among the commercial features in its documentation. With it you create returns directly in the administration and track the status per line item. Before you plan, check whether the feature is included in your plan and whether it covers your processes. For a returns portal with label printing and exchange, many stores use an extension or their carrier’s solution.
Whichever tool you use, the reason must be attached to the item and be available for evaluation. Transfer the reasons to your ERP system or evaluate them monthly as an export. A custom field on the product can hold the fit hint you derive from the reasons.
If you lack the time for this setup: in the solution25 shop subscription, our team builds and runs the store. According to the current page, Scale costs 299 euros per month and Pro 499 euros per month, each with a 24-month minimum term and no setup fee. Enterprise is available on request. Scale includes, among other things, the setup of payment methods and shipping, hosting in Germany, updates and backups. Pro includes extended payment methods and shipping rules, a dedicated contact person and a monthly report. Enterprise covers integrations such as ERP systems. A returns portal is not named as a service on the page. Ask about it if you need one.
| Metric | What it shows | Rhythm |
|---|---|---|
| Return rate per item and category | Where the problem sits | Monthly |
| Share of each reason | Which measure fits | Monthly |
| Cost per return | What every avoided return is worth | Every six months |
| Share of exchanges in all returns | How much revenue you keep | Monthly |
| Time until restocking | How long goods cannot be sold | Monthly |
| Conversion rate of the affected pages | Whether a measure costs orders | With every change |
The last row is important. A lower return rate is not a success if orders collapse at the same time. What matters is what remains after returns: revenue minus returned goods minus return costs. Measure every measure against this number. How to keep an eye on the conversion rate is covered in the article on conversion optimisation in the online shop.
That depends on the industry. According to the University of Bamberg, almost every fourth parcel was sent back in Germany in 2021. For shoes and clothing the share is considerably higher, for electronics and books considerably lower. Compare yourself with your industry and with your own previous months.
Under German law the consumer bears the direct cost of returning the goods if you informed them about this and do not cover the cost yourself. Have your withdrawal policy checked before you switch, and check the rules of each country you sell to.
As a rule yes, but they can also cost orders. Test the change on one category and measure revenue after returns, not just the rate.
For fashion and shoes, usually better information on fit. For products that need explanation, clear descriptions and help after the purchase. Your recorded return reasons show which measure works for you.
That is legally delicate and often wrong commercially. First check the profit per customer and get legal advice before you block accounts.
solution25 is a Shopware Platinum Partner from Bremen, Germany, and has worked on online shops since 2017. Together with you we look at where returns arise: product pages, payment methods, processes after the order. This becomes a short list of measures your team can implement and an evaluation that shows whether they work. We do not promise a specific rate.
The shop analysis gives a first look from the outside. For adjustments in a running store, Shopware support is the right route. We answer questions via the contact page. If you want to hand over setup and operations, you will find the packages in the shop subscription.

Besnik Bilalli is the founder and CEO of solution25, the Shopware agency from Bremen. Before founding the agency in 2017, he built his own online store and grew it to more than 500 orders a day. Since then he has been helping merchants with Shopware projects, from the first budget to ongoing operations. He’s happy to answer questions about this article personally: get in touch.
Responsible for content and updates: Besnik Bilalli. Last updated: November 2026. Next content review: February 2027.